Police break up plot to assassinate Turkish pastor

Two of the suspects 'were like family' in the church

By Dan Wooding
Founder of ASSIST Ministries

(Photo: World Watch Monitor)

Some of the other suspects also had visited the church, Karaali told World Watch Monitor. He said three of the suspects are women.

"These people had infiltrated our church and collected information about me, my family and the church and were preparing an attack against us," said Karaali, 33, a native Turk and a convert to Christianity. "Two of them attended our church for over a year and they were like family."

Accounts of the arrests in Turkish media reported that the suspects were planning to murder Karaali this week during a series of evangelistic outreach meetings.

"They caught them last minute," said Hakan Tastan, an Istanbul Christian who was visiting Izmit Wednesday. "If they had waited one week, we would have lost them," he said, referring to the pastor, his family and potentially other church members.

The 14 had collected personal information, copies of personal documents, created maps of the church and the pastor's home, and had photos of those who had come to Izmit to preach. In one of the homes raided by police, two guns were found, Turkish media reported. Police have recorded the telephone conversations of the 14 suspects.

Press reports said the Izmit anti-terror police decided to close in when they learned the network of suspects had brought in someone from Diyarbakir, in eastern Turkey, to carry out the murder.

"The police are not talking about the arrests, claiming their investigation is ongoing," added the World Watch story.

Karaali said he learned about the arrests reading the morning newspaper Wednesday. Later that day, he said, the police called him in for questioning and a briefing that lasted more than five hours.

He said police showed him photos of some of the 12 suspects who, unlike the remaining two suspects, had not been regularly attending the church. He said he recognized some of the 12 as occasional visitors. Karaali said his treatment at the hands of the police was "exceptional."

The pastor said he has been working with police since January 2012, when he informed them of a death threat he had received.

"I received a threat by phone and that's when the police started to investigate," Karaali said. It's not yet publicly known whether any of the suspects arrested Tuesday are connected to that initial phone threat.

Karaali said he declined police protection that was offered at that time, though his wife and two young children did move into an apartment building with better security. Another threat was made during the summer.

"They said, 'You talk too much. We're hearing your voice everywhere and we're going to break your head.' They didn't say they'll kill me exactly, but that if I didn't shut up it would be bad." Police have not revealed whether any of the 14 suspects arrested this week are suspected of making the threat.

World Watch Monitor said that Izmit, about 100 miles east of Istanbul, is the heart of an industrial region of about 1 million people, known for the devastation it faced in the earthquake of 1999 that claimed thousands of lives. The Izmit Protestant Church, operating for 13 years, is a small congregation, ministering to 20 people, all of whom are Turkish converts to Christianity. Karaali and his wife have served the church for four years, in an environment he described as difficult.

"Every region of Turkey has its challenges," he said. "What is difficult about our city is that the people here are closed and there are many radical groups making it a hard place for the church. The anger towards us continues."

A Christian visiting the Izmit Church this week described a group of children yelling insults at those who were leaving an evening meeting. Earlier this week, a passerby threw rocks and hurled expletives at the church.

"There is hate and this hate feeling continues from people here," Karaali said of the attitude of the locals toward the church. "They look at us strangely. Unfortunately that continues. We've been trying to make known what Christianity is about. There are those who come to us who are warm and well-intentioned, but ones who hate us also come unfortunately."

Karaali's predecessor, Wolfgang Hade, a German, also had received death threats during his time as pastor in Izmit, and was under police protection for a year after the 2007 murders of three Christians in the eastern city of Malatya. The accused ringleader of the Malatya murders had said he was planning on killing Hade next.

The Istanbul Protestant Church Foundation, of which the Izmit church is a member, denounced the alleged assassination plot in a press statement Thursday.

"These types of assassination attempts are a black stain that some want to spread on Turkey making it a spectacle to the world," the statement read. "We stand against those who attack different faiths in our country. Instead we prefer the upholding of the virtues of love and brotherhood, which is the core of tolerance."

Karaali said he intends to continue to pastor his small flock.

"Two years ago I almost lost my life because of my health, but the Lord brought me back to life and he has done this for me again," he said. "He protects us, so we believe this means the Lord has work for us to do. We haven't lost our confidence. On the contrary, we feel the Lord is with us because he didn't allow this (assassination) to happen, and we will continue to do what the Lord asks. We will continue. We will continue."

Turkey was ranked No. 31 on the 2012 World Watch List, a ranking of the 50 countries where life as a Christian is most oppressed, as measured by Open Doors International, a ministry to persecuted Christians. Turkey did not rank among the top 50 in the 2013 World Watch List.